diff --git a/lib/views/globalsettingsappearanceview.dart b/lib/views/globalsettingsappearanceview.dart
index 59abce76..f3dfc336 100644
--- a/lib/views/globalsettingsappearanceview.dart
+++ b/lib/views/globalsettingsappearanceview.dart
@@ -352,7 +352,7 @@ class _GlobalSettingsAppearanceViewState extends State<GlobalSettingsAppearanceV
       case "juniper":
         return "Juniper"; // Juniper is a noun, and doesn't get subject to translation...
     }
-    return settings.themeloader.themes[theme]?[settings.theme.mode]?.theme ?? theme;
+    return settings.themeloader.themes[theme]?[mode_light]?.theme ?? settings.themeloader.themes[theme]?[mode_dark]?.theme ?? theme;
   }
 
   void importThemeCheck(BuildContext context, Settings settings, String themesDir, String newThemeDirectory) async {